Academic review

Know which students to discuss before you meet.

Upload your school’s results early in the term to see which students may need a closer look. Leaders can review the results ahead of time and use the meeting to talk through what students need.

Meeting brief

[Student]’s writing

EvidenceTalking points
Review [date]

Files you can use

The files your school already has.

Upload the files your school systems already export. You can use them as they are without setting up a live connection.

Gradebooks

Upload term or assessment grades by subject or year group. ScholarED saves each upload as a separate assessment.

Subject reports

Use subject results from your school platforms that give each skill or criterion its own column.

Assessment results

Bring end-of-term, mock or classroom results in the format you use, including IB grades, percentages, letter grades, IGCSE-style results or your own format.

Tests and notes

See PSAT 8/9 rosters and NWEA MAP Growth exports or reports alongside the notes teachers add to a student’s profile.

Use a CSV or XLSX spreadsheet export or a PDF report. For a pilot, you can anonymize the file first.

What ScholarED looks for

See the patterns and the results behind them.

You’ll see one entry per student, with an explanation and the results behind it. Your team decides who needs a plan.

The same difficulty more than once
The student fell below the pass mark in the same area at least twice in a row.
Several subjects at once
The student is struggling in more than one subject or class.
A gap shared by the class
When at least a fifth of the class has the same gap, ScholarED flags it so the class team or department can plan a shared response.
What changed
Once support begins, you can compare the next assessment with the earlier results side by side.

Start with Urgent review, then move to Review recommended and Monitor closely. The order helps your team make time for the students who need attention first.

Leadership review

Come to Monday’s review ready to make a plan.

Pull the results together in a brief ahead of time so leaders can spend the meeting deciding what to do next.

The brief includes

Students to discuss
Across subjects and assessments
Changes across a class
Whole-class and year-group trends
Student plans and Follow-ups
Who’s following up, how it’s going, and what’s next
Plans due for review
Which plans to discuss at this meeting

Your team decides what to do.

Use the patterns in the brief to start the conversation and agree on what students need.

Check what changed at the next assessment.

Upload the next set of results to see how students are doing since your team agreed on support.

FAQ

How academic review works

What happens in an academic review meeting?
School leaders and teachers look at results together, decide who needs support and agree on what to try next. Before you meet, ScholarED shows whose results are worth discussing and prepares a brief.
Why does a student appear in Needs review?
ScholarED looks for patterns in the results you upload. It checks for the same difficulty at least twice in a row, low results in several subjects or a gap affecting at least a fifth of the class. Each entry tells you why it’s there and which results it’s based on.
Who appears first in Needs review?
The list starts with Urgent review, followed by Review recommended and then Monitor closely. That gives your team a place to start when you meet.

Next step

What happens after the review?

After looking at the results together, write down what you’ve agreed to try and check how it’s going at the next assessment.